IP Port Forwarding

[Mikeymikey]

Hello, I recently have tried to setup a SRCDS (Source Dedicated Server) and it seem people can't connect or even see it on their server list. When I had my old router, it worked fine, this one probably should too. Additionally, I sometimes get "Bad Challenges," does that mean that people can actually ping it or see it? I've also did a port check for port 27015 (The one I have open on my router) and it says it is open. Although no one still can see it.
Command Line : c:\srcds\srcds.exe -console -game cstrike +map de_dust -maxplayers 16 -autoupdate.
I use to have it setup right, and use to be able to have people connect no problem. Any ideas? (I just tried a DMZ, still did not work, I don't think it is compatible with my router maybe?) My router is a Netgear FVS318 Tried it with my other netgear router and it worked fine.. but i don't want to use it. Also with the router I discovered it could be seen by game-monitor. I have recently discovered that people can connect if i give IP.
Quick Recap:

• My old router showed up on my serverlist.
• My ports are correctly port forwarded.
• I can see my server on game-monitor, and says adding to master server.
• I can see on my LAN server listing.
• My router model is Netgear FVS318.
  

Okay, I guess I just can't see it on my Serverlist for public...

[Drocona]

you could try the DMZ option and see if it shows up then, I'm afraid a lot of routers won't make it to the master list.

[Mikeymikey]

Drocona Wrote:you could try the DMZ option and see if it shows up then, I'm afraid a lot of routers won't make it to the master list.

As said above, I figured out that I myself couldn't see it with my new router, my old router I could see it fine. I also did a DMZ, but when I added it to my "favorites" it didn't show up. But, when I told a friend to add it, it was fine. My old router worked fine and showed up on the "favorites" list. It's just strange, but I can live with it (all I can't see is that it's on favorites, it's under the "lan" tab though so it's all good). Anyways, thanks for the reply, although I really didn't need it (I probably should have deleted this thread, but I left it for reference in case someone had the same problem on me (with the same router model)).

[Drocona]

Mikeymikey Wrote:As said above, I figured out that I myself couldn't see it with my new router, my old router I could see it fine.

Oops, sorry missed it

Well I'm afraid some routers will never make the server show up at the main list, why? I have no idea. But that's why I always try to avoid routers, they never work as you want them to.